North Sea Ecosystem Has Crossed a Point of No Return, Scientists Warn

Our analysis of 40 years of data from the North Sea reveals something unsettling: this heavily fished and rapidly warming ecosystem has crossed a threshold and fundamentally reorganized itself in ways that appear irreversible. We found evidence of a previously undetected regime shift that challenges how we think about ocean recovery.

We wanted to answer a deceptively simple question: when marine ecosystems undergo dramatic changes, can they bounce back? The North Sea is one of the most heavily human impacted marine areas in the world, experiencing both intensive fishing pressure and rapid warming. We assembled 40 years of data covering everything from plankton to commercially important fish species, then applied catastrophe theory and stochastic cusp modeling to detect regime shifts and test whether they showed hysteresis—the technical term for irreversibility.

Our findings were stark. The North Sea ecosystem had experienced a regime shift driven by the combined effects of fishing and warming, and this shift appeared irreversible. Previous studies had documented ecosystem changes in the 1980s and 1990s, but they focused on subsets like plankton or fish populations and used methods that couldn't quantify hysteresis. Our comprehensive analysis revealed that the ecosystem as a whole had crossed a tipping point and settled into a new stable state.

"What we found most troubling was the lack of any clear path back."

What we found most troubling was the lack of any clear path back. While reducing fishing pressure might help increase yields of currently exploited species, simply removing fishing pressure is unlikely to reverse the regime shift because other feedbacks now maintain the new state. These feedbacks stabilize the new regime through the creation of new interactions among species, new energy pathways, and new system structures.

This matters because it changes how we think about marine conservation and management. If ecosystems can cross points of no return, then preventing regime shifts becomes more important than trying to reverse them. Since climate change cannot currently be reversed and can only be mitigated, the new regime in which the North Sea now resides appears permanent.

Citation

Sguotti, Camilla; Blöcker, Alexandra M.; Färber, Leonie; Blanz, Benjamin; Cormier, Roland; Diekmann, Rabea; Letschert, Jonas; Rambo, Henrike; Stollberg, Nicole; Stelzenmüller, Vanessa; Stier, Adrian C.; Möllmann, Christian (2022). Irreversibility of regime shifts in the North Sea. Frontiers in Marine Science.

Read the full paper

This paper is Open Access.