Scientists Develop Early Warning System for Ocean Ecosystem Collapse

We discovered that marine ecosystems don't always change gradually—sometimes they flip suddenly when environmental pressures cross invisible tipping points. A team of thirteen scientists led by Jameal Samhouri spent years analyzing two decades of data from the California Current System to understand when these dramatic shifts occur.

We wanted to answer a crucial question: How can we tell when gradual environmental changes or human activities will trigger sudden, massive ecosystem responses? Traditional monitoring focuses on tracking average conditions over time, but We suspected that wasn't enough. They developed a framework using multiple statistical models—gradient forest analysis and generalized additive models—to hunt for nonlinear relationships in the data. They analyzed nine ecosystem indicators, from tiny copepods to sea lion populations, against sixteen different environmental and human pressures.

Our analysis revealed that five ecosystem states showed threshold responses to various pressures. Both of their analytical methods agreed on two specific cases: winter copepod populations responding to habitat modification, and sea lion pup production responding to summer patterns in the Pacific Decadal Oscillation. Most striking was their finding that as many as five ecosystem indicators may exhibit threshold changes in response to negative Pacific Decadal Oscillation values in summer—copepods, scavengers, groundfish, and marine mammals all showed potential threshold responses to this climate pattern.

The Pacific Decadal Oscillation's influence appeared to cascade across multiple trophic levels in nonlinear ways. We expected climate to affect ecosystems, but seeing these threshold patterns across so many different groups of organisms revealed the extent of climate's nonlinear influence across the food web.

This matters because the California Current System supports more than $23 billion in revenue from fisheries, tourism, and recreation. The approach provides a new way to interpret changes in environmental and human pressures as they relate to ecological integrity. Instead of just monitoring whether things are getting worse or better on average, managers can now identify when they're approaching dangerous tipping points where small additional changes might trigger large ecosystem shifts.

We note that these insights can be used to make more informed assessments of when and under what conditions intervention, preparation, and mitigation may enhance progress toward ecosystem-based management goals.

Citation

Samhouri, Jameal F.; Andrews, Kelly S.; Fay, Gavin; Harvey, Chris J.; Hazen, Elliott L.; Hennessey, Shannon M.; Holsman, Kirstin; Hunsicker, Mary E.; Large, Scott I.; Marshall, Kristin N.; Stier, Adrian C.; Tam, Jamie C.; Zador, Stephani G. (2017). Defining ecosystem thresholds for human activities and environmental pressures in the California Current. Ecosphere.

Read the full paper

This paper is Open Access.